Ed Doney Reporting , KFOR
March 9, 2010
OKLAHOMA CITY -- A bill that would require insurance companies to cover treatment for children with autism has cleared the House of Representatives in Missouri. However, the fight continues over similar legislation in Oklahoma, called "Nick's Law." The father of 12-year-old Nick Rohde, for whom the proposed law was named, wants Oklahoma to join surrounding states on the issue.
Wayne Rohde spends thousands of dollars every month for Nick's autism behavioral therapy, which is not covered by insurance and yet Nick is still unable to verbally communicate with his dad.
Wayne has unsuccessfully tried to get lawmakers to pass Nick's Law and is amazed at how Oklahoma is surrounded by states that do cover the disease like Colorado, New Mexico, Texas and Louisiana.
As Missouri inches closer to providing autism coverage, Wayne says that 65 percent of Oklahomans are on his side.
"So we know we're on the right track. This is the right thing to do," he says. "Unfortunately, our State Capitol is not listening to the people of Oklahoma."
Representative Mike Brown (D, District 4) has authored House Joint Resolution 1068, which would "refer (the issue) to the people for their approval" on the November ballot.
He says it's currently being held up in a rules committee.
Brown was disappointed Nick's Law was killed last year in the Economic Development and Financial Services Committee, which means it won't be heard again until 2011.
"You can't just turn your head, stick your head in the sand and say it's going to go away," Brown says.
He points to 15 other states that have already passed autism coverage legislation that, he says, has not significantly raised insurance premiums.
"Will there be slight (cost) increases? My gosh, there's astronomical increases every year in health care, with no reasons behind it," Brown says.
Representative Dan Sullivan (R, District 71) is Chairman of the committee that killed Nick's Law, last year.
"We see a movement in the market without government intervention that's taking care of these situations and moving in the right direction," he says.
Sullivan points out that Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Oklahoma is now offering autism coverage on their own; he wants other insurance companies to follow their lead, without an expensive government mandate.
If they don't follow suit?
"It would certainly cause us to go back to these other carriers and say, 'why aren't you doing this? Give us a reason why you're not doing this?'" Sullivan says. "We would rather have people do it in their own course of business rather than forcing and mandating them to do that."
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Oklahoma released a statement Tuesday saying "(We) will provide a clinically reasonable benefit that doesn't unduly create a price impact on small employer groups and affect their ability to provide health care coverage to their employees. This action allows us to provide a benefit for proven therapeutic services while research continues to identify effective treatments or medical solutions for children with autism."
Wayne Rohde is disappointed Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Oklahoma's autism policy does not cover behavioral therapy, which he says is the most important and most expensive treatment for children.
"We're creating a bigger problem down the road in the next few years," he says, "where the taxpayers will be on the hook to provide long-term care for these kids as they become adults."
Copyright © 2010, KFOR-TV
http://www.kfor.com/news/local/kfor-news-autism-bill-nicks-law-story,0,2313781.story
Showing posts with label Rep Dan Sullivan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rep Dan Sullivan. Show all posts
Saturday, March 13, 2010
Monday, April 27, 2009
Democrats walk off Oklahoma House floor
The Associated Press
Published: April 27, 2009
Democrats in the Oklahoma House walked out of the chamber Monday after their attempt to revive an insurance coverage mandate for autism was blocked by the House's Republican majority.
"This is totalitarian government," Rep. Joe Dorman, D-Sand Springs, said after all but a handful of the House's 40 Democrats walked off the floor following a series of parliamentary maneuvers in which Democrats attempted to revive the autism mandate known as "Nick's Law."
"We're just shocked," said House Democratic leader Danny Morgan of Prague. He said parliamentary rulings by the House's presiding officer at the time, Rep. Don Armes, R-Faxon, will make the House's Democratic minority ineffective as a political power.
"It really restricts our ability to make legislation," Morgan said. "Hopefully we'll be able to sit down and express our concerns and frustrations."
After Democrats walked out, the House voted 65-0 to send the autism provider bill to Gov. Brad Henry for his signature, with eight Democrats voting with Republicans.
The bill calls for enactment of a licensing process for national board certified behavior analysts and enhancement of existing state programs that would train doctors to diagnose and treat autism.
During a legislative study last year, lawmakers learned that a shortage of trained providers has made it difficult for families to obtain autism services, even when they have financial assistance.
Supporters of "Nick's Law" have argued that therapists will not move to the state to provide services to autistic children without a guaranteed revenue stream to pay them, like that provided by mandated health insurance coverage.
Parliamentary bickering began when Rep. Mike Brown, D-Tahlequah, made a motion to amend legislation backed by GOP leaders that is designed to increase the provider network of autism specialists in Oklahoma.
The amendment would have revived "Nick's Law," which would require private insurance companies to pay for the diagnosis and treatment of autistic children. The measure, named after an 11-year-old autistic boy from Edmond, Nick Rohde, would cap benefits at $36,000 a year.
The amendment was not considered after Rep. Dan Sullivan, R-Tulsa, said House rules prohibited it because the House Economic Development and Financial Services Committee that he chairs made a do-not-pass recommendation on Nick's Law earlier this year, effectively killing it for two full years under House rules.
Armes ruled that Brown's amendment was out of order, prompting Brown to make a motion to suspend the rule that prevented his amendment from being heard, a motion that requires a two-thirds vote of the House to prevail.
"We have suspended those rules for whatever the majority wants to do," Brown said, pointing out that GOP motions to suspend rules regarding germaneness and other parliamentary issues have been routinely passed.
But Armes said his ruling was based on the precedent of past House rulings, not House rules, and that House precedent took priority over the rules.
"We're relying on House precedent. This bill's dead," Armes said. Brown appealed the ruling of the chair, but it was upheld by the GOP majority.
"House precedent holds that final action on legislative language is in fact that, final action," Republican House Speaker Chris Benge of Tulsa said later in a statement. "The Democrats had recourse to appeal the ruling of the chair, and they lost that vote."
Dorman, a former member of the American Institute of Parliamentarians, said it marked the first time he is aware of that any legislative body had ruled that precedent superseded rules voted on by the members.
"Precedence outweighs any of our rules. We can't write a new rule and we can't suspend the rules," Dorman said. If a bad ruling by the presiding officer is placed into the House's book of precedents, then the chamber will forever be governed by that bad ruling, he said.
"That's insane," Dorman said.
"There ought to be some formula that we can look at," Morgan said. "I'm concerned about that."
click here to leave an online comment.
Published: April 27, 2009
Democrats in the Oklahoma House walked out of the chamber Monday after their attempt to revive an insurance coverage mandate for autism was blocked by the House's Republican majority.
"This is totalitarian government," Rep. Joe Dorman, D-Sand Springs, said after all but a handful of the House's 40 Democrats walked off the floor following a series of parliamentary maneuvers in which Democrats attempted to revive the autism mandate known as "Nick's Law."
"We're just shocked," said House Democratic leader Danny Morgan of Prague. He said parliamentary rulings by the House's presiding officer at the time, Rep. Don Armes, R-Faxon, will make the House's Democratic minority ineffective as a political power.
"It really restricts our ability to make legislation," Morgan said. "Hopefully we'll be able to sit down and express our concerns and frustrations."
After Democrats walked out, the House voted 65-0 to send the autism provider bill to Gov. Brad Henry for his signature, with eight Democrats voting with Republicans.
The bill calls for enactment of a licensing process for national board certified behavior analysts and enhancement of existing state programs that would train doctors to diagnose and treat autism.
During a legislative study last year, lawmakers learned that a shortage of trained providers has made it difficult for families to obtain autism services, even when they have financial assistance.
Supporters of "Nick's Law" have argued that therapists will not move to the state to provide services to autistic children without a guaranteed revenue stream to pay them, like that provided by mandated health insurance coverage.
Parliamentary bickering began when Rep. Mike Brown, D-Tahlequah, made a motion to amend legislation backed by GOP leaders that is designed to increase the provider network of autism specialists in Oklahoma.
The amendment would have revived "Nick's Law," which would require private insurance companies to pay for the diagnosis and treatment of autistic children. The measure, named after an 11-year-old autistic boy from Edmond, Nick Rohde, would cap benefits at $36,000 a year.
The amendment was not considered after Rep. Dan Sullivan, R-Tulsa, said House rules prohibited it because the House Economic Development and Financial Services Committee that he chairs made a do-not-pass recommendation on Nick's Law earlier this year, effectively killing it for two full years under House rules.
Armes ruled that Brown's amendment was out of order, prompting Brown to make a motion to suspend the rule that prevented his amendment from being heard, a motion that requires a two-thirds vote of the House to prevail.
"We have suspended those rules for whatever the majority wants to do," Brown said, pointing out that GOP motions to suspend rules regarding germaneness and other parliamentary issues have been routinely passed.
But Armes said his ruling was based on the precedent of past House rulings, not House rules, and that House precedent took priority over the rules.
"We're relying on House precedent. This bill's dead," Armes said. Brown appealed the ruling of the chair, but it was upheld by the GOP majority.
"House precedent holds that final action on legislative language is in fact that, final action," Republican House Speaker Chris Benge of Tulsa said later in a statement. "The Democrats had recourse to appeal the ruling of the chair, and they lost that vote."
Dorman, a former member of the American Institute of Parliamentarians, said it marked the first time he is aware of that any legislative body had ruled that precedent superseded rules voted on by the members.
"Precedence outweighs any of our rules. We can't write a new rule and we can't suspend the rules," Dorman said. If a bad ruling by the presiding officer is placed into the House's book of precedents, then the chamber will forever be governed by that bad ruling, he said.
"That's insane," Dorman said.
"There ought to be some formula that we can look at," Morgan said. "I'm concerned about that."
click here to leave an online comment.
Friday, February 6, 2009
House Committee Kills Autism Bill
ouse Committee Kills Autism Bill
Posted: Feb 3, 2009
FEATURED VIDEO
House Committee Shoots Down Autism Bill
Autism is currently not covered by healthcare in Oklahoma, restricting many families' ability to provide treatment to children with Autism.
Autism is currently not covered by healthcare in Oklahoma, restricting many families' ability to provide treatment to children with Autism.
Parents await the committee's decision. They were outraged by the results.
Autistic disorder is characterized by impaired verbal and non-verbal communication, social interaction, some form of repetitive and restricted stereotyped interest, ritual, or other behavior.
By Dave Jordan, NEWS 9
OKLAHOMA CITY -- Oklahomans battling autism came from across the state hoping to convince the House Economic and Financial Committee that they should pass this measure, but the Republican-controlled committee did not because it felt that such a vote would cause insurance rates to spike.
Doctor Juliet Burk did everything to convince them otherwise. After her two sons were diagnosed with autism at an early age, the self-proclaimed conservative Republican left Oklahoma and moved back to her native New York state to seek treatment for her children that Oklahoma did not provide.
"Somebody said, "Where's your validation for services?" Dr. Burk said. She pointed to her son next to her.
Dr. Burk moved back to Oklahoma and now has a thriving medical practice in Tahlequah. She said her sons no longer show signs of autism and the medical care they received was cost-effective.
"These guys were not expensive because there was a funded infrastructure that they could access right away," Dr. Burk said.
Because the authors of House Bill 1312 failed to specify an insurance premium increase, the measure was shot down.
Nine voted in favor, five against, but it failed to pass.
Wayne Rhode, whose son Nick is the inspiration for the bill, is outraged.
"These folks are struggling," Rhode said. "These parents are struggling to provide what they need for these families. This is shameful."
Rhode was one of more than a dozen families who came to the capitol in support of the bill.
"I challenge them right now to look at these parents and tell these parents that their children are not going to receive any help because of this actions," Rhode said.
Representative Daniel Sullivan (R-District 71), who chaired the committee said it was a risk he didn't want to take.
"What we do not want to have occur is additional increases in premiums where people that have insurance now are added to the uninsured and it makes this whole cycle so much worse," Representative Sullivan said.
The committee passed a motion to increase the number of therapists for autistic children. It also passed a measure preventing the House from bringing Nick's Law back to committee for at least two more sessions.
A similar bill could have a chance in the Senate.
Critics of an insurance mandate believe the market will drive autism coverage. Their example is Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oklahoma, which has added limited benefits for children with autism.
Posted: Feb 3, 2009
FEATURED VIDEO
House Committee Shoots Down Autism Bill
Autism is currently not covered by healthcare in Oklahoma, restricting many families' ability to provide treatment to children with Autism.
Autism is currently not covered by healthcare in Oklahoma, restricting many families' ability to provide treatment to children with Autism.
Parents await the committee's decision. They were outraged by the results.
Autistic disorder is characterized by impaired verbal and non-verbal communication, social interaction, some form of repetitive and restricted stereotyped interest, ritual, or other behavior.
By Dave Jordan, NEWS 9
OKLAHOMA CITY -- Oklahomans battling autism came from across the state hoping to convince the House Economic and Financial Committee that they should pass this measure, but the Republican-controlled committee did not because it felt that such a vote would cause insurance rates to spike.
Doctor Juliet Burk did everything to convince them otherwise. After her two sons were diagnosed with autism at an early age, the self-proclaimed conservative Republican left Oklahoma and moved back to her native New York state to seek treatment for her children that Oklahoma did not provide.
"Somebody said, "Where's your validation for services?" Dr. Burk said. She pointed to her son next to her.
Dr. Burk moved back to Oklahoma and now has a thriving medical practice in Tahlequah. She said her sons no longer show signs of autism and the medical care they received was cost-effective.
"These guys were not expensive because there was a funded infrastructure that they could access right away," Dr. Burk said.
Because the authors of House Bill 1312 failed to specify an insurance premium increase, the measure was shot down.
Nine voted in favor, five against, but it failed to pass.
Wayne Rhode, whose son Nick is the inspiration for the bill, is outraged.
"These folks are struggling," Rhode said. "These parents are struggling to provide what they need for these families. This is shameful."
Rhode was one of more than a dozen families who came to the capitol in support of the bill.
"I challenge them right now to look at these parents and tell these parents that their children are not going to receive any help because of this actions," Rhode said.
Representative Daniel Sullivan (R-District 71), who chaired the committee said it was a risk he didn't want to take.
"What we do not want to have occur is additional increases in premiums where people that have insurance now are added to the uninsured and it makes this whole cycle so much worse," Representative Sullivan said.
The committee passed a motion to increase the number of therapists for autistic children. It also passed a measure preventing the House from bringing Nick's Law back to committee for at least two more sessions.
A similar bill could have a chance in the Senate.
Critics of an insurance mandate believe the market will drive autism coverage. Their example is Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oklahoma, which has added limited benefits for children with autism.
Oklahoma House committee kills autism mandate
to read comments click here.
By The Associated Press
Published: February 3, 2009
Buzz up!
OKLAHOMA CITY — Legislation to require health insurers to cover the diagnosis and treatment of autism was killed Tuesday evening by a state House committee that effectively blocked the mandate proposal from being considered in the House again for two years.
Advertisement
Click here to find out more!
Instead, the Republican-controlled House Economic Development and Financial Services Committee unanimously approved legislation to increase the number of certified therapists for autistic children.
Supporters said an autism coverage mandate would drive up health insurance rates in Oklahoma and that it is meaningless to consider one until there are enough therapists to do the job.
"The discussion we're having today, in my opinion, is premature," said House Speaker Pro Tem Kris Steele, R-Shawnee, author of the therapist bill. "We're not ready for this kind of mandate because the services do not exist."
"I don't believe that providing a promise without a solution is what we need," said the committee's chairman, Rep. Dan Sullivan, R-Tulsa.
Supporters of the mandate bill, known as "Nick's Law" after for an 11-year-old autistic boy from Edmond, Nick Rohde, argued that therapists will not move to the state to provide services to autistic children without a guaranteed revenue stream to pay them, like that provided by mandated health insurance coverage.
"Without any help, we know where they're going to end up," said the bill's author, Rep. Mike Brown, D-Tahlequah, who said taxpayers eventually will have to pay for the care of dysfunctional autistic children.
Autism is a bioneurological disability that affects communication skills in young children, many of whom also suffer from ailments such as allergies, asthma and epilepsy. Officials estimate it affects about one out of every 150 children in the U.S.
Along party lines, committee members voted 10-5 against a motion to send the autism mandate measure to the House floor as dozens of autistic children, their parents and other family members crowded into House meeting rooms to hear discussion and debate on the autism bills.
It then voted 9-5 for a do-not-pass motion that under House rules will prevent the mandate idea from being considered again until a new Legislature is seated in 2011.
"The language is dead — really dead," Brown said. "It cannot be heard for two years.
"They wanted this off the plate," Brown said of House Republican leaders. "They did not want to deal with that."
Autism mandate legislation was passed by the Senate last year but was blocked in the House. Similar legislation is pending in the Senate again, but Sullivan said he will not schedule a hearing on the bill if it reaches the House.
After the meeting, some parents held photographs of their autistic children as lawmakers left the meeting room.
"It was a foregone conclusion," said Wayne Rohde, Nick's father. "What are they telling us back there? That we don't want to help these kids to the level that we need to?"
While Medicaid covers some services for the autistic children of low-income families and the wealthy can afford to pay, middle-income families struggle to afford behavioral and occupational therapies for their children. Rohde has said he spends up to $5,000 a month for therapy for his autistic son.
"You're throwing those parents into bankruptcy," Brown said.
Eight other states have passed the same autism mandate legislation and 10 states have similar laws, Brown said. Thirty-two states are considering a mandate to provide some relief to the families of autistic children.
"And the best thing we can do is look them in the eye and tell them to move to another state?" asked Rep. John Carey, D-Durant, a member of the committee.
"That's exactly what we're doing," Brown said.
The mother of two autistic children, Dr. Juliet Burk of Tahlequah, said she left her practice in Oklahoma and moved in with family members in upstate New York where mandated therapies were provided at no direct cost. Therapies for one son cost $30,000 a year.
"We left to find a funded infrastructure," said Burk, a self-described conservative Republican who said early and intense therapy for her children helped reverse their autism diagnosis.
Brown disputed a study performed for the state House that said an autism mandate would increase health insurance rates by at least 7.8 percent and possibly as high as 19.8 percent.
Brown said other studies, including one by the Oklahoma State and Education Employees Group Insurance Board, concluded the cost would be 1 percent or less
By The Associated Press
Published: February 3, 2009
Buzz up!
OKLAHOMA CITY — Legislation to require health insurers to cover the diagnosis and treatment of autism was killed Tuesday evening by a state House committee that effectively blocked the mandate proposal from being considered in the House again for two years.
Advertisement
Click here to find out more!
Instead, the Republican-controlled House Economic Development and Financial Services Committee unanimously approved legislation to increase the number of certified therapists for autistic children.
Supporters said an autism coverage mandate would drive up health insurance rates in Oklahoma and that it is meaningless to consider one until there are enough therapists to do the job.
"The discussion we're having today, in my opinion, is premature," said House Speaker Pro Tem Kris Steele, R-Shawnee, author of the therapist bill. "We're not ready for this kind of mandate because the services do not exist."
"I don't believe that providing a promise without a solution is what we need," said the committee's chairman, Rep. Dan Sullivan, R-Tulsa.
Supporters of the mandate bill, known as "Nick's Law" after for an 11-year-old autistic boy from Edmond, Nick Rohde, argued that therapists will not move to the state to provide services to autistic children without a guaranteed revenue stream to pay them, like that provided by mandated health insurance coverage.
"Without any help, we know where they're going to end up," said the bill's author, Rep. Mike Brown, D-Tahlequah, who said taxpayers eventually will have to pay for the care of dysfunctional autistic children.
Autism is a bioneurological disability that affects communication skills in young children, many of whom also suffer from ailments such as allergies, asthma and epilepsy. Officials estimate it affects about one out of every 150 children in the U.S.
Along party lines, committee members voted 10-5 against a motion to send the autism mandate measure to the House floor as dozens of autistic children, their parents and other family members crowded into House meeting rooms to hear discussion and debate on the autism bills.
It then voted 9-5 for a do-not-pass motion that under House rules will prevent the mandate idea from being considered again until a new Legislature is seated in 2011.
"The language is dead — really dead," Brown said. "It cannot be heard for two years.
"They wanted this off the plate," Brown said of House Republican leaders. "They did not want to deal with that."
Autism mandate legislation was passed by the Senate last year but was blocked in the House. Similar legislation is pending in the Senate again, but Sullivan said he will not schedule a hearing on the bill if it reaches the House.
After the meeting, some parents held photographs of their autistic children as lawmakers left the meeting room.
"It was a foregone conclusion," said Wayne Rohde, Nick's father. "What are they telling us back there? That we don't want to help these kids to the level that we need to?"
While Medicaid covers some services for the autistic children of low-income families and the wealthy can afford to pay, middle-income families struggle to afford behavioral and occupational therapies for their children. Rohde has said he spends up to $5,000 a month for therapy for his autistic son.
"You're throwing those parents into bankruptcy," Brown said.
Eight other states have passed the same autism mandate legislation and 10 states have similar laws, Brown said. Thirty-two states are considering a mandate to provide some relief to the families of autistic children.
"And the best thing we can do is look them in the eye and tell them to move to another state?" asked Rep. John Carey, D-Durant, a member of the committee.
"That's exactly what we're doing," Brown said.
The mother of two autistic children, Dr. Juliet Burk of Tahlequah, said she left her practice in Oklahoma and moved in with family members in upstate New York where mandated therapies were provided at no direct cost. Therapies for one son cost $30,000 a year.
"We left to find a funded infrastructure," said Burk, a self-described conservative Republican who said early and intense therapy for her children helped reverse their autism diagnosis.
Brown disputed a study performed for the state House that said an autism mandate would increase health insurance rates by at least 7.8 percent and possibly as high as 19.8 percent.
Brown said other studies, including one by the Oklahoma State and Education Employees Group Insurance Board, concluded the cost would be 1 percent or less
Wednesday, February 4, 2009
Opinion - Bixby Bulletin
Opinion
‘Nick’s Law’ Quickly Trampled in Committee
Published:
Interests of Insurance Companies Continue to Trump Needs of FamiliesWednesday, February 4, 2009 5:59 PM CST
OKLAHOMA CITY (February 4, 2009) State Capitol – Events in play leading up to the hearing on Nick’s Law foreshadowed the failure of the measure to receive a judicious or fact-based reception. An actuarial analysis requested by Republican leadership and attached to Nick’s Law was created with instructions to approach the analysis with annual caps $25,000 higher than allotted in Nick’s law, thus skewing the fiscal impact of the bill. House Rules adopted in short notice allowed little debate and no allowances as to the rules killing language for two years if either unheard or failing to pass in committee.
The Chair of the Economic Development and Financial Services Committee, Representative Daniel Sullivan, held a private conference one hour prior to the committee hearing to explain to members of the media the rules and procedures he would enforce in the coming meeting, and House staff sent at the bequest of Democratic Leader Danny Morgan and Democratic Floor Leader Mike Brown to attend this informational meeting was barred from entering the meeting. Long story short, the Economic Development and Financial Services Committee is stacked with nine (9) Republican legislators and five (5) Democratic legislators, and in a mere two hours Nick’s Law lived and died along partisan lines and by those unwilling and indifferent to consider the plight of children with autism.
“Last year, one of my former Republican colleagues took a lot of grief by not granting this bill a hearing,” said Floor Leader Brown, D-Tahlequah. “So this year they switched strategies. They brought up the bill in committee early just to quickly vote it down. This isn’t lawmaking – this is game playing, and they’re playing games with kids’ lives. There’s no excuse for it.”
According to House Rules, the language within Nick’s Law, or any similar language attempting to allow insurance coverage for autism, is denied re-entry in the form of an amendment or a bill this year and next.
“Rep. Sullivan blatantly stated that Nick’s Law is finished for two years – end of story. Legislators are bowing to the interests of insurance companies, who as we all know are not benevolent in practice and constantly seek methods in which to have the best return on profits by providing the least amount of service. Both the Senate and House Republicans have openly expressed their allegiance to the insurance industry, and have proven this allegiance by their actions on Nick’s Law.
It’s apparent that only the Democrats are willing to fight the insurance companies and stand up for these families.”
“In the end, it’s not just these families and these children who will pay for our lack of action. All Oklahomans will pay – when a middle-class family goes broke trying to pay for their kid’s treatment, we will have to foot the bill while they pick up the pieces. We will pay an astronomical price over the lifespan of each autistic child unable to receive the proactive services available but unaffordable to families. I find the actions of my colleagues across the hall shameful, and yesterday marked a sad day not only for Oklahoma families, but for those who should have stood up for Nick’s Law and instead choose to stand up for the interests of insurance companies.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)